Black Friday Deals

Product Image

DeLonghi Magnifica Start

449,95 $ 599,95 $

You save: 150,00 $ (25%)

Go to the offer
Product Image

DeLonghi La Specialista Touch

599,95 $ 799,95 $

You save: 200,00 $ (25%)

Go to the offer
Product Image

DeLonghi Eletta Explore

1.499,95 $ 1.999,95 $

You save: 500,00 $ (25%)

Go to the offer
Product Image

Bosch 500 Series

679,00 $ 799,00 $

You save: 120,00 $ (15%)

Go to the offer
Product Image

Smeg Manual Espresso Machine

399,95 $ 499,95 $

You save: 100,00 $ (20%)

Go to the offer
Product Image

Smeg ECF03 (Pastel Blue)

599,95 $ 699,95 $

You save: 100,00 $ (14%)

Go to the offer
Product Image

Smeg ECF03 Cold Brew

599,95 $ 699,95 $

You save: 100,00 $ (14%)

Go to the offer
Product Image

Smeg EGF03 (Red)

799,95 $ 999,95 $

You save: 200,00 $ (20%)

Go to the offer
Product Image

Smeg Semi-Automatic (Matte Black)

799,95 $ 999,95 $

You save: 200,00 $ (20%)

Go to the offer
Product Image

Ninja Luxe Café Premier

499,99 $ 599,99 $

You save: 100,00 $ (17%)

Go to the offer
Product Image

DeLonghi La Specialista Arte Evo

449,95 $ 699,95 $

You save: 250,00 $ (36%)

Go to the offer
Product Image

KitchenAid KF8

1.799,95 $ 1.999,99 $

You save: 200,04 $ (10%)

Go to the offer
Product Image

KitchenAid KF7

1.449,95 $ 1.699,99 $

You save: 250,04 $ (15%)

Go to the offer
Product Image

KitchenAid KF6 (Porcelain White)

1.049,99 $ 1.199,99 $

You save: 150,00 $ (13%)

Go to the offer
Product Image

KitchenAid KF6 (Stainless Steel)

1.049,99 $ 1.199,99 $

You save: 150,00 $ (13%)

Go to the offer

Brita Water Filter for Coffee: Will Your Coffee Taste Better With Brita?

Hi! My name is Arne. Having spent years working as a barista I'm now on a mission to bring more good coffee to the people. To that end, my team and I provide you with a broad knowledge base on the subject of coffee.

Clearly explained: Our review process

Coffee is about 98 percent water. Most folks use tap water to make coffee. However, tap water often contains copper, lime, chlorine and sometimes even a tiny trace of lead. A Brita water filter for coffee is designed to help with that – whether as a separate water filter pitcher or as a filter cartridge in a fully automatic espresso machine.

The brand has managed to convince all of us that our tap water isn’t the best choice for achieving the best coffee flavor. Not to mention the risk of limescale buildup in a coffee maker’s pipework and nozzles.

Is that true? In a previous post, I took an in-depth look at water filters for automatic espresso machines. In this article, I’ll talk about Brita water filters in general and the Brita water filter pitcher in particular. After all, it’s become an almost standard accessory for coffee lovers. I want to know whether or not that’s justified.

Advantages & Disadvantages: Brita Water Filter for Coffee

PROS

  • Reduces water hardness & limescale
  • Softer water produces better cup results
  • Easy to use and clean
  • Good value for money
  • Long-lasting filters

CONS

  • Requires frequent refills
  • Other, less expensive options available
  • Filter life often overestimated
  • Your water doesn’t necessarily need filtering
  • Filtered water doesn’t make up for sub-quality coffee beans

Limescale & Water Hardness: Effects on Coffee Flavor

As in many regions of the United States, German tap water isn’t just good – it’s outstanding. It undergoes more rigorous and stricter testing than any other product. But what comes out of the faucet isn’t always the best choice for making coffee.

This is due to dissolved calcium and magnesium minerals. Depending on the condition of your pipes and the path the water takes through the rock from the water table, a high concentration of these minerals can accumulate in tap water, leading to significant limescale buildup in your coffee equipment.

The higher the mineral content, the higher the water hardness, which in Germany is expressed by the unit “German hardness” (dH):

  • Values below 8 °dH = soft, low-mineral water

  • Values between 8 – 14 °dH = moderately hard water

  • Values above 14 °dH = hard, very calcareous water

The German national average water hardness is 16 °dH. For perfect drip coffee, a maximum of 3 °dH is recommended; for espresso, a maximum of 6 °dH. This is because the more calcium compounds (and other small impurities) there are in the water, the less “room” there is for the extraction of flavors and coffee compounds.

In addition, limescale has a distinctive, chalky taste that makes your drink taste sour. You won’t get a decent crema either, and on top of that, limescale crystals build up in pipes, heating elements, valves and nozzles.

How Does a Brita Water Filter Work?

Brita water filters are multi-stage “strainers” designed to remove impurities from tap water mechanically or through chemical and physical processes. A Brita water pitcher or filter cartridge for fully automatic espresso machines has several filter stages. Let’s take a quick look at how the pitcher works.:

  1. Gravity: When tap water is poured into the water filter pitcher from above, it flows through the entire filter cartridge and all filter stages.

  2. Activated carbon: Activated carbon is an effective filter for metallic impurities, to which it binds and thereby neutralizes.

  3. Ion exchanger: An ion exchanger actually exchanges ions – specifically, calcium ions for sodium ions. If there is no calcium, there is no limescale buildup.

First things first: My friends at Schweizer Kaffeemacher conducted a thorough test and found that the Brita water filter pitcher is actually really good at removing limescale. So I can generally recommend using it for drip coffee machines or making pour-over.

Filter cartridges in fully automatic coffee makers serve a similar purpose, and definitely influence the resulting cup profile in this regard.

What Else Can a Brita Water Filter Do?

So far, so good. From here on out, though, things often get a little “tin foil hat” – literally. Because if you believe some Brita devotees, pure poison is what comes out of the faucet.

In some places, chlorine, hormones or other substances may be a problem. In Germany, I’m pretty sure they aren’t.

To some extent, the manufacturer’s somewhat vague marketing is also to blame for this belief, even though they don’t claim that their filters help combat toxins.

So if you’re wondering whether you should switch to using only bottled water at home or buy a Brita filter for every faucet … you don’t have to. If the limescale on every glass or the chalky color of your tiles bothers you, then I’m happy to recommend a Brita. But which one?

Brita’s Range of Products

Brita X Large Water Dispenser

The Brita water filter pitcher is the most popular option because it’s compact, portable and fits in the fridge. But Brita has come up with more ideas. Lots more.

  1. X-Large Water Dispenser with a 218-ounce (6.5-liter) capacity. Brita claims you can also keep the X-Large dispenser in the fridge.

  2. Filtering water bottles in different styles and materials for use on the go.

  3. Brita Hub Countertop Water Filtration System.

  4. Several faucet water filter attachments.

  5. Intenza water filter cartridges for coffee machines.

All Brita pitchers have an electronic “SmartLight” indicator that lets you know when the filter needs changing. Plus, there are three kinds of filter cartridges: Original, Plus and Elite. If you buy a pitcher that takes an Elite filter, the manufacturer claims you’ll only need to change it every six months. As for the standard filter, that’ll need to be changed at least every two months.

Brita Water Filters for Fully Automatic Coffee Machines

While Brita dominates the water pitcher market, it’s only a bit player in the coffee maker filter segment. Under the name Intenza, Brita markets filter cartridges for a limited number of brands, including Gaggia, Bosch and Philips.

The important thing to note here is this: A Brita filter reduces limescale buildup in the machine and extends the time between cleaning cycles. However, it does not eliminate the need to descale the machine.

How Often Should You Replace Brita Filters?

The frequency with which you should replace your Brita filter depends on the model you’re using. For example, according to the manufacturer, an original Brita filter cartridge lasts for around 40 gallons (150 liters). Then again, this is just a rough estimate, seeing as the hardness of your water plays a large part.

So, if you live in Las Vegas, you can expect to change your Brita filter more often, whereas residents of Seattle will be able to stretch it out for longer..

My tip: Measure your water hardness with a test strip. You can get these for next to no money on Amazon. That way, you’ll have a good idea of roughly how long your filter will last.

Should I Keep My Brita Pitcher in the Refrigerator?

Brita Pitcher Water Filter for Coffee

Although a Brita water pitcher fits perfectly in the refrigerator, it shouldn’t become a permanent fixture there. Water may look harmless, but it’s one of the best breeding grounds for germs, bacteria and algae.

If you keep the pitcher in the fridge all the time and just keep pouring more water into the flip-top lid, limescale, chlorine or anything else will be the least of your worries. Cleaning it after every use is a must.

Brita Water Pitcher Tested by Stiftung Warentest

I’ve referred to Stiftung Warentest in other articles – it’s a German consumer organization that tests products in order to help folks make informed purchases.

From unnecessary to harmful, leaving more contaminants behind than before and filter cartridges with poor durability: that’s Stiftung Warentest’s verdict on Brita water filters. The organization conducted its most recent test in 2022, when it inspected models from several manufacturers.

Apparently, the filter’s performance was far worse – or its lifespan much shorter – than promised. In addition, they found germs and mold inside. So is the Brita water filter a piece of junk after all?

Yes and no. While the brand came out on top in the Stiftung Warentest evaluation, it received only a “Satisfactory” rating (3.5).

The issue with reduced filter performance isn’t surprising. The cartridges are where brands make most of their money. Besides, I don’t expect anything more from a filter than for it to prevent as much limescale as possible.

Cleaning a Brita Water Pitcher: Can It Go in the Dishwasher?

Of course, even with the best Brita model, cleaning is a must. In my opinion, it’s pretty obvious what can and can’t go in the dishwasher.

You can wash the pitcher without any problems, as well as the filter housing. The filter cartridge itself, of course, cannot be washed, and you should handwash the lid with the SmartLight indicator.

Comparison & Tips: Are There Alternatives to Brita for Descaling?

As you might imagine, there are plenty of alternatives to the Brita water pitcher available on Amazon and other sites. However, the materials used for the lid, pitcher and other parts of most third-party products tend not to be of lesser quality. Furthermore, the price difference is often minimal.

You can save a lot on the filter cartridges, though. An Amazon Basics set is way cheaper and also fits in Brita water filters. The more cartridges per set, the better the deal.

Final Thoughts on the Brita Water Filter: You Don’t Really Need It

Can you actually make good coffee with tap water? You bet! It doesn’t matter whether you live in Phoenix or Portland. But limescale is still a problem – and it’s not just noticeable in the cup.

If you want to enhance the taste after you’ve optimized all other settings and parameters, a Brita water filter is a useful accessory for your fully automatic coffee maker or home espresso machine.

Coffee connoisseurs who pay close attention to nuances and different roast profiles will notice the difference. Your coffee makers will also benefit.

In short, unless you live in an area with particularly hard water, or somewhere with known water contamination issues, I see no reason to clutter your kitchen with a Brita pitcher or dispenser.

What has your experience with Brita water filters for coffee been like? Feel free to leave a comment!

Coffeeness US Community Updates
Stay informed about the latest test reports, blog posts and products on Coffeeness.
Your coffee expert
Team Image
Arne Preuss

Hi! My name is Arne. Having spent years working as a barista I'm now on a mission to bring more good coffee to the people. To that end, my team and I provide you with a broad knowledge base on the subject of coffee.

More about Arne Preuss

Hi! My name is Arne. Having spent years working as a barista I'm now on a mission to bring more good coffee to the people. To that end, my team and I provide you with a broad knowledge base on the subject of coffee.

More about Arne Preuss

Subscribe
Notify of

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Table of Contents