2021 Rancilio Silvia Review: Putting the Art in Artisanal Coffee

OK, so this may be the German in me coming out, but I think that the Rancilio Silvia is to espresso machines what the G-Class is to off-road vehicles: not new or big on frills, but a timeless classic with an aura of indestructibility.

OK, so this may be the German in me coming out, but I think that the Rancilio Silvia is to espresso machines what the G-Class is to off-road vehicles: not new or big on frills, but a timeless classic with an aura of indestructibility.

Fortunately, at $795 (brand-new) and $300 upward (second-hand) on Amazon, this Rancilio Silvia espresso machine review proves this espresso machine offers significantly better value for your money than those boxes on wheels. Even if the design aesthetics are strikingly similar.

There have been a few upgrades to Miss Silvia since Rancilio started production in 1998. As a result, the machines have different brewing thermostats.

Low price, high power.

Rancilio Silvia

Low price, High Power.

Excellent workmanship

Compact appliance

Minimalistic

Good steaming power

Easily available parts (simple construction = easy DIY)

Temperature stability = awesome espresso

Milk froth requires skill

Risk of rust if poorly operated

At a nuts and bolts level, there’s a single boiler with a vibrating pump.

With that and the price tag in mind, the Rancilio Silvia offers a real bang for your buck in terms of power delivered from the boiler to the steam wand.

The bottom line: you can beautifully texture milk in no time for your Cappuccino. At least that’s true once the machine heats up, which will take about 20 minutes.

Something else that will take a bit of time is getting a feel for the machine. Aside from learning how to froth milk, temperature surfing with the Rancilio Silvia is another key skill that I cover in more detail later on.

Not only is the Rancilio Silvia a beautifully crafted and constructed espresso machine that offers great value for your money, but it’s also built to last — I know several kitchens where the Rancilio Silvia has offered faithful service for over 10 years.

To seal the deal, good spare parts are freely available. And though it might not be top of mind when shopping for a machine, it’s pretty important.

Getting to Grips With the Rancilio Silvia User Manual

First things first: here’s what you’ve got to work with as far as tech specs go.

CategoryEntry
ManufacturerRancilio
NameMiss Silvia
Weight30.8 lb
Dimensions9.2 x 11.4 x 13.3 in
Power1100 W
Boiler typeSingle boiler
Water tank0.53 gal

And if you prefer your manuals in electronic format or just like to be extra thorough and preview them before buying, you can download the PDF here.

The Silvia Sisters: V1 vs V6 Models

The Rancilio Miss Silvia has graced shelves and retail portals for quite some time. Along the way, there have been various modest updates.

I’m guessing the “V” stands for version and not something cool in Italian. Either way, it’s basically the product code. So the higher the number (with V6 being the latest), the newer the model.

The only difference between the V3 to V4, for instance, is that the heating element is screwed in rather than welded to the boiler.

What does that mean for the home barista? Nada.

In other words, if there’s no real price hike between updates, the newer version is first prize. But if you can get a great deal on a used model, go for it!

Keep an eye out for pimped-out machines. Some people can tune a machine to achieve incredible things. 

Hello, 2020 model! So once again, there’s nothing drastically new to report — just that the group head now has a black cover, and the new tamper is a bit heavier with a wooden handle.

Does the Rancilio Have Your Name (And Not Just Silvia's) Written On It?

This is always a tricky question.

You’re obviously looking at portafilters right now, which is a move in the right direction. But you should know that if you want a proper espresso machine and not a super-automatic, you’ve got to be willing to learn the ropes, including:

  • Learning the machine’s ins and outs
  • Immersing yourself in the art of brewing espresso
  • Getting the best out of your coffee grinder
  • Frothing milk correctly

While it’s thrilling to pursue the perfect espresso, it’s also a game of patience, involving lots of trial and error. What works well for one coffee bean could backfire on the next.

As is true of all portafilters, the Rancilio espresso machine needs your care and attention — and ideally your devotion. 

This is an entry-level model for people who want to let their inner baristas out at home.

And thanks to its awesome results, a lot of people in the coffee community recommend it. So if you have about $800 to play with, it should be your first choice.

The Sum of the Rancilio Silvia's Parts Is Greater Than Its Price

The Rancilio Silvia espresso machine is a surprisingly solid espresso machine for its price.

If well-cared-for, it can last for years or even decades to come. Plus, the single-boiler unit comes wrapped up in a lovely steel casing.

You can also choose whether you prefer the steel brushed or polished. Personally, I think the matte look just screams portafilter.

Small But Mighty Portafilter

Despite its bulk and a rather thick handle, the portafilter sits nicely in your hand — even for someone with smallish fists like me.

When I weighed it, it came in at well over 21 ounces. And thanks to the logo, it also packs quite a design punch.

Arne holding the portafilter that comes with the Rancilio Silvia.

For this review, I popped in the double espresso filter because it gives me better results — I’ll need to do more testing with the single-shot filter.

If you ask me, I’d grab a bottomless portafilter at the same time as you buy the Rancilio Silvia, especially since it’s not too pricey on Amazon. Sure, you’ll lose out on some of that lovely weight in the hand, but it won’t affect the espresso quality.

In fact, here are some of the advantages:

  • The espresso comes into contact with less metal.
  • That means it’s cooled less.
  • With a much better view of the extraction process, you can tweak the settings better, which is especially helpful because the Rancilio Silvia doesn’t have a pressure gauge.

A Brief Word on the Water Tank — It Gets the Job Done

Fixed in the back of the Rancilio Silvia is the water tank, which means to remove it, pull it upwards.

I won’t lie to you, a slightly higher-quality lid would be nice. But remember, the fuller it is, the harder it is to remove.

So overall, it does the job well enough.

How Many Is Too Many Switches?

The Rancilio Silvia has four rocker switches, starting with the one with the two LED lights, which you use to turn the machine on or off.

Then there are the three switches positioned one on top of the other: the top one is for espresso, the middle one is for hot water and the bottom one produces steam.

Switches on the Rancilio Silvia.

Many people prefer metal switches, but I don’t think you can complain about these. Sure, these are plastic, yet still, feel like quality to the touch.

Rancilio Silvia Drip and Cup Trays — Nothing to Write Home About

While nice enough, the cup tray is really nothing special.

Unfortunately, though, it’ll get scratched, which is as inevitable here as it is with other espresso machines.

I must admit a steel drip tray is a nice touch that adds to the high-quality feel of the machine as a whole.

Below, you can see the Rancilio Silvia without the drip or cup tray. And once again, you can’t help admiring the beautiful, minimalist design as all parts slot neatly and easily back into place.

Even still, I strongly advise that you make a point of checking if there’s water under the drip tray. You definitely want to avoid this at all costs. Otherwise, you risk rusting — one more reason to ensure the tray is pushed snugly into the back of the base.

The Rancilio Silvia without drip or cup tray.

How to Finesso Your Espresso

With the Rancilio Silvia, you can make (or to use the lingo, “pull”) a really good shot of espresso.

To do so, you have to be clued up on the technical side of things — then again, that’s true of all espresso machines.

For starters, it’s not just your grinds that have to be fresh from the mill, but the beans themselves must also be newly roasted.

With that, this seems as good a time as any to give you a step-by-step guide to the perfect espresso.

Mind Your Grind

Getting your grind size just spot-on is seriously important.

To complicate matters, the definition of “spot-on” can vary from bean to bean and may need to be tweaked with each new espresso. If the brew extracts — for example, the full half ounce (for a single) or just over one ounce (for a double) has landed in your cup — in under 25 seconds, you need to adjust the grind finer.

Grinding beans for the Rancilio Silvia.

So what if it takes longer than 25 seconds or is just dripping out of the spout? Grind a little coarser.

And it’s not just the grind size that matters. Quality is a factor, too.

You can tell how good a grinder is by how evenly it crushes up your beans. That’s because coffee particles of a uniform size mean the espresso also extracts more evenly.

Which Coffee Grinder Is the Best Match for Miss Silvia?

Admittedly, I feel like I’m banging my head against a brick wall when it comes to tips on coffee and espresso grinders.

So here’s my advice in its simplest form:

Whatever you spend on the portafilter, budget the same for a grinder.

The truth is, I’ve noticed that people are a lot less willing to cough up for a grinder than they are for an espresso machine.

For those on a tight budget, go for the Baratza Sette 30 coffee grinder. It’s great value for money and delivers solid results.

If you carefully eyeballed the picture above, you may be saying, “That’s not the Baratza Sette!”

Nope, it’s the Eureka Mignon, which you can snap up on Amazon for just under $480. In terms of both design and functionality, this nifty little burr grinder makes a cute couple with the Rancilio Silvia. It even has a timer to help you control dose size.

The easy way out is to get an espresso machine with a grinder. And yes, such all-in-one machines exist.

In fact, the Breville Barista Express is about $100 cheaper than the Rancilio Silvia. But the nature of such hybrid beasts is compromised, and that’s most obvious on the grinder. Read my review of the Breville Barista Express to get the full picture.

The Breville Barista Express espresso machine with grinder.

Another espresso machine with a grinder is the Breville Oracle Touch. But that’s a whole new ballpark in terms of price ($2,500) and levels of automation.

The Dosing Dossiers

Again, you can spend hours experimenting with this. As a ballpark, work with between 7 to 9 grams for a single shot and 14 to 19 grams for a double espresso. Grams are more accurate for dosing, so the metric system wins on this one.

Often the smaller quantities deliver better results, so don’t go too large too soon.

How to Tamp Like a Champ

The only thing that the lightweight, plastic tamper you got with previous versions of the Rancilio Silvia was good for was the garbage. It’s totally useless.

One of the updates to the V6, which was released in 2020, is a new tamper with a wooden handle. I’ve heard that it’s got some decent heft to it.

But I’m a feeling-is-believing guy, so I’m reserving judgment, especially as crummy tampers are a common problem, even with more expensive espresso machines. It’s always worth adding to your espresso equipment with a nice, heavy one.

The tamper with the Rancilio Silvia V4.

So what should you look for in a tamper? For the Rancilio Silvia, you’ll need one with a size of 58 millimeters (2.28 inches).

In my opinion, heavier is always better.

Aside from that, it’s a matter of taste. I’m a fan of well-balanced tampers. That and the stainless steel on the LuxHaus Espresso Tamper makes it (literally) a solid choice. Plus, it costs just under $30.

Locked and Loaded — Docking the Portafilter

Properly docking the portafilter below the brew unit is, of course, pretty critical.

Luckily, this is pretty easy with the Rancilio Silvia. The important thing is to really tighten it.

When securely locked into place, the handle isn’t exactly centered in the middle. Instead, it’s offset slightly to the right, as you can see in the second photo. The spout also screws on and does not have to line up perfectly — I know that a lot of readers get uptight about this.

Remember to pull at least one blank shot — for example, letting hot water run through the portafilter without any coffee — before loading up the grinds. This rinses out any dirt and heats the portafilter up.

A cold portafilter cools your espresso down a whole lot, which is one of the reasons why I recommend the bottomless version.

Watch and Learn: Pulling an Espresso Shot

Since the Silvia doesn’t have a pressure gauge, the only way to find out if all the various factors are coming together nicely is to keep a beady eye on the extraction process. To be honest, that’ll tell you everything you need to know.

Here’s a quick troubleshooting guide:

  • Why does the espresso pour out of only one spout? Either uneven tamping or the grind is not uniform enough.
  • Why does the espresso extract too fast? The grind is probably too coarse.
  • Why does the espresso extract too slowly? The grind is probably too fine.

I rate the extraction that you can see in the pics as fairly decent. It was a touch on the slow side. With these espresso beans, I obviously need to nudge the grind size slightly coarser.

By the way, I’m never 100 percent satisfied with any shot. For me, the journey is the destination.

Everyone's Favorite Part — Enjoy Your Espresso!

I can’t say it often enough: don’t allow yourself to get so wrapped up in the settings and variables that you forget what its purpose is.

Take as much time over sipping and contemplating the flavors as you do tweaking variables. Otherwise, what’s the point?

Barista Arne drinks espresso from the Rancilio Silvia.

Cool Beans or Not? Which are the Best for Espresso?

The first prize is always freshly roasted espresso beans from the roastery you trust. Stale beans just ruin your espresso.

Never use beans that are more than three months old. So that rules out supermarkets because the beans are unfortunately never newly roasted.

Online distributors have the same problem. The coffee sits on shelves for too long.

For this reason, it’s always worthwhile ordering directly from the roaster. People who are passionate about coffee and their product don’t ship stale espresso beans.

Making Milk Froth With the Rancilio Silvia's Steam Wand

Miss Silvia builds a really nice head of steam. Thanks to that power, the steam wand feels like it’s attached to a much bigger espresso machine.

If you’d like a tutorial on how to whip up gorgeous microfoam, check out my frothing guide. I strongly recommend that you get a thermometer, too. 

Here are my suggested steps:

  1. Turn on the steam switch.
  2. Open the faucet to release water into a cloth.
  3. Close it again for a few seconds. After you open it again, wait until the steam is dry.
  4. Froth according to the instructions.
  5. Close the faucet and thoroughly wipe any milk residue off the wand. Otherwise, it’ll just get hard and be difficult to get off.
  6. Finally, open once more to purge milk residues out of the wand.
The steam wand on the Rancilio Silvia.

Of course, timing all this on-again, off-again takes a bit of practice. So don’t lose heart even if you haven’t totally cracked it after the third or fifth attempt. Since the machine is virtually indestructible, you’ve got years to hone your skills.

Temperature Surfing With the Rancilio Silvia

Single boilers struggle with the necessary drop in temperature from producing steam for milk froth to brewing, with the result that you can end up with burnt or bitter espresso. Nasty.

Temperature surfing is the solution. It allows you to intervene manually and compensate for the espresso machine’s shortcomings.

Once you’ve got it down, and it’s part of your coffee-making routine, you’ll hardly even think twice about it.

Alternatively, you can always buy a machine with a heat exchanger. But for many, the budget just won’t stretch that far.

With that in mind, you might be ready to roll up your sleeves. If so, here’s a great guide to temperature surfing.

Retrofit the Rancilio Silvia or Pimp My Portafilter?

If you’ve been doing your research, you may have noticed that a lot of people recommend retrofitting a PID controller (proportional-integral-derivative controller) to the Rancilio Silvia because of the brewing thermostat’s wide hysteresis.

What? The thermostat has some sort of big emotional meltdown?

Nah, hysteresis just means that the boiler temperature can’t be lowered quickly enough when switching between frothing milk to brewing.

To froth milk, you need steam. Water only turns to steam at high temperatures. And in a pressurized boiler that’s over 212 degrees Fahrenheit. The problem is water that hot burns your beautiful espresso and turns it into undrinkable slop. This is a typical single-boiler issue.

So steam exploding out of the portafilter is a big no-no. And the water should be hot — about 194 degrees Fahrenheit — but liquid. 

A Rancilio Silvia PID accurately controls water temperature to within one degree. No more relying on your temperature surfer instincts. Perfect temperature, perfect espresso. Every time.

Rust Busting on the Rancilio Silvia

Unfortunately, rust is a very real risk with portafilters.

And on the Rancilio espresso machine, the bottom of the drip tray seems to be most vulnerable. Once spotted, you need to remove the rust and prevent it from spreading.

Lots of Rancilio Silvia reviews don’t mention this at all, which is a real oversight. So you’ll see reviewers who’ve never owned the machine or only had it for a few days write: “I haven’t had any problems with rust.”

Well, duh! Rust doesn’t develop that fast.

Most often, rust on the Rancilio Silvia is caused by water from the three-way valve’s outflow splashing water up behind the drip tray.

This is because the outflow sits very high up and the water spatters in weird directions on its long journey down.

There are a couple of small but effective tricks to help you beat rust. If you’re religious about them, you shouldn’t have a problem.

The solution? Lengthen the outflow. An ordinary old piece of PVC hose with a diameter of about three-quarters of an inch works a charm.

Next, take a closer look at the drip tray. There’s a bit of play on it inside the frame, so ensure it’s pushed right up against the back. To keep it there, wedge it tight with a small piece of wood or plastic.

How to Clean the Rancilio Silvia

Aside from wiping and flushing the steam wand after use as I describe above, the big cleaning questions on an espresso machine revolve around descaling:

  • How often do you need to descale?
  • What products should I use to descale?

I’m working on a longer article about descaling in general, but you should know that the problem is, there are no one-size-fits-all answers for the Rancilio Silvia — or any other machine.

Everything depends on how hard — for example, how high the mineral content — of your water is.

Harder water equals more mineral deposits and more frequent descaling. How often you use your Rancilio espresso machine is the other factor you need to take into account.

I advise descaling at least once a year. And there’s no need for harsh chemicals if you’re not keen on those. Citric acid does the trick. Choose the longest possible soaking time, so that the nasty white deposits break down thoroughly.

It’s also a good idea to backflush with water as often as possible.

Once a month, use a coffee oil detergent, such as Puly Caff. But you can be very sparing with it — the tip of a teaspoon is enough. After all, you want as little of it as possible in the machine.

Second-Guessing Yourself About Buying the Rancilio Silvia Second Hand?

This is always a tough decision.

I mean, I hemmed and hawed for quite a while over new versus used before getting my La Pavoni Professional off the shelf — with the mindset of honing my hands-on skills).

Still, I’ve been keeping an eye on Rancilio Silvia machines on eBay to get a better idea of prices on the second-hand market. There’s not much below $300, and even espresso machines with defects can command that price.

This isn’t to say that there aren’t some machines in outstanding condition for a bargain price.

Miss Silvia is not a complicated lady and parts are freely available. So not only is it easy to replace gaskets, but you don’t need an engineering degree to give her a tune-up.

There’s also definitely something to be said for the satisfaction you get from giving something old a new lease on life — and doing your bit to curb throwaway culture.

When buying second-hand, ask the seller a few questions:

  • How did they clean the machine?
  • Why do they want to sell it?
  • What tips can they offer on descaling?

My experience is that people who know espresso machines inside and out, treat them well and love an opportunity to chat about them.

For me, that’s far more important than how old the appliance is. Besides, the Rancilio Silvia often just whets the appetite for more high-end espresso machines.

Though an espresso fiend buys the Silvia with a cheap grinder, they’re quick to realize their mistake and get a new grinder that costs more than the espresso machine. One thing leads to another, and they upgrade the machine itself, too.

What I’m getting at with this little story is that there are lots of home baristas out there looking to sell their beautifully maintained Rancilio Silvia to get a new espresso machine that costs just over $1,000.

My Verdict on the Rancilio Silvia: Big Thumbs Up

The Rancilio Silvia is a very solid, sturdy espresso machine that enjoys cult status for good reason. Plus, it delivers a lot of power for an appliance of its class.

The only downside is that it takes a bit of time to heat up. So I advise turning the machine on 20 minutes before making a Cappuccino.

Low price, high power.

Rancilio Silvia

Low price, High Power.

Excellent workmanship

Compact appliance

Minimalistic

Good steaming power

Easily available parts (simple construction = easy DIY)

Temperature stability = awesome espresso

Milk froth requires skill

Risk of rust if poorly operated

There’s a good supply of spare parts, and you can snap up a bottomless portafilter basket to round out your espresso equipment for very little. And thanks to great temperature stability, the quality of the espresso is top-notch. At just under $800, this is great value for your money.

With care and maintenance, this is an espresso machine that will last and last. Compared to other espresso machines, pulling a good espresso is relatively easy on the Silvia. But as with any portafilter, you’ll need to practice texturing milk.

Alternatives to the Rancilio Silvia

For those who want a pressure gauge or hate hanging around waiting for the machine to heat up, check out the QuickMill Silvano Evo. But expect a bigger price tag.

Comparing the Rancilio Silvia and Quickmill Silvano Evo.

Thanks to a single boiler and thermoblock combo, the QuickMill Silvano Evo is ready to make espresso and milk froth in minutes.

The Gaggia Classic Pro is another stainless-steel-clad, single-boiler portafilter designed in Italy. Like the Rancilio Silvia, it’s a great choice for anyone keen to earn their home barista stripes.

The big, in-your-face difference is price. At just under $450, you can just about get the Gaggia Classic Pro, plus a great grinder for the price of the Silvia.

Of course, it’s never that cut and dry.

With its 3.5-ounce boiler, the Gaggia Classic Pro heats up faster and is quicker to return to brew temperature after steaming. But the Rancilio Silvia’s 12-ounce boiler will let you pull more shots back-to-back and froth milk for longer.

The full view of the Gaggia Classic Pro.

The general consensus is that Miss Silvia makes the superior espresso, though both machines produce beautiful froth. Plus, the Rancilio’s steam wand has an incredible range of motion, and once mastered, is more versatile.

Have you gotten your hands on a Rancilio Silvia, or are you planning on it? How does it stack up, or what would you like to know before deciding? Give us a shout in the comments. Thanks for reading!

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Kommentare
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Table of Contents