Coffee vs Tea: Which Is Healthier?

Hi! My name is Arne. Having spent years working as a barista I'm now on a mission to bring more good coffee to the people. To that end, my team and I provide you with a broad knowledge base on the subject of coffee.

Our review process | Our team

In the hot beverage world, one debate reigns supreme: coffee vs tea. Each boasts a variety of flavors and a legion of devoted drinkers.

In the hot beverage world, one debate reigns supreme: coffee vs tea. Each boasts a variety of flavors and a legion of devoted drinkers.

But beyond drinking coffee and tea, an age-old question lingers: which is healthier?

Today, I’ll explore this question further, discussing health benefits and potential drawbacks. From antioxidant potency to caffeine levels, I’ll unpack it all.

So, let’s get into this battle of the brews to see what’s what!

Overview: Coffee vs Tea

Coffee and tea have long histories that span continents and centuries.

Coffee’s journey began in Ethiopia in 850 CE. Legend has it that a goat herder discovered its stimulating effects on his herd. From there, coffee spread to Yemen and the Arabian world. Eventually, drinking coffee became the norm, igniting a global love affair.

Coffee plant

Tea has a much longer history. It has its origins in ancient China, dating back to the Shang dynasty in 2737 BCE. The Chinese have since enjoyed it for its medicinal properties, and it’s now a cultural staple. From here, tea gained popularity all over Asia before reaching the West at the end of the 16th century.

In time, both coffee and tea became famous not only for their refreshing qualities, but also their health benefits.

Research shows that drinking coffee reduces blood sugar and the risk of developing chronic diseases like Alzheimer’s and Parkinsons. Regular coffee consumption may also improve brain function and physical performance.

Similarly, tea, rich in antioxidants called polyphenols and catechins, promotes reduced inflammation and the risk of heart disease. Crucially, tea also contains L-theanine, which promotes mental clarity, relaxation and sleep.

But beyond their health benefits, how has the coffee vs tea question integrated into our everyday lives? Since the 12th century, coffeehouses have long been intellectual and social hubs. From the sidewalk coffee kiosks of the Middle East and Asia to the bustling cafés of Europe, coffee culture has defined everyday life.

But tea went next level, becoming the very essence of ceremony and ritual. So much so that it formed the center of sacred Japanese sado, Chinese gong fu and Indian chadhool ceremonies.

Later, tea became a cornerstone of English culture, especially in the Victorian era, which birthed the tradition of English afternoon tea. From here, the British Empire did much to spread tea culture worldwide.

Coffee vs Tea: Factors to Consider

So how do these two delicious drinks compare in the coffee vs tea debate? Let’s look at some important factors to consider regarding these two iconic beverages.

Flavor Profiles

One of the most significant differences between coffee vs tea is their flavor profiles

Coffee is robust and slightly bitter, with earthy, chocolaty, nutty or fruity notes. These flavor profiles depend on the bean variety, origin and roast level. From the epitome of Italian coffee culture, the espresso, to creamy cappuccino and mellow cold brew, coffee offers flavors to suit every palate.

Slider Image
Slider Image
Slider Image

Tea is a whole other animal. It boasts more delicate, nuanced tastes. For instance, green tea boasts earthy undertones, purple tea floral, woody notes and black tea a malty richness.

Notably, each tea variety offers a unique sensory and taste experience.

Caffeine Levels

Caffeine in coffee and tea is what gives these brews their energizing effects. But, crucially, the amount of caffeine in coffee vs tea varies, depending on the coffee bean or tea leaf.

Coffee reigns supreme when it comes to caffeine content. An 8-ounce (236-milliliter) morning coffee, the ultimate pick-me-up and go-to beverage, contains 80 to 140 milligrams of caffeine. This amount of caffeine in brewed coffee depends on the variety (Robusta has more caffeine than Arabica), roast level (dark roast coffee has less caffeine) and brewing method.

In contrast, a single espresso shot has 68-70 milligrams of caffeine. Instant coffee, however, is quite different. Depending on the brand it can have 39-90 milligrams.

On the other end of the caffeine spectrum come heavyweights: cold brew and nitro. These super-charged brewed coffees have 155 and 215 milligrams, the highest levels of coffee caffeine yet.

Conversely, tea generally contains less caffeine, when you do a coffee vs tea comparison across the spectrum. These levels also depend on the leaf variety, roast level and preparation method.

Still, tea provides a welcome caffeine boost but without the intensity. For instance, a standard 8-ounce cup of black tea contains 50 milligrams of caffeine. Interestingly, matcha and green tea levels are marginally higher: 60 and 40 milligrams, respectively. How can this be, you may very well ask me? Well, matcha tea is, in effect, powdered green tea, and undergoes no oxidation at processing. Similarly, green tea (unlike black tea), undergoes very little heating, thereby retaining its caffeine during processing.

Tea drinkers that favor Darjeeling, oolong, purple and white teas also consume some caffeine, but that not much, really. In contrast, herbal tea has zero caffeine, making it the go-to caffeine-free alternative.

Antioxidants

Both coffee beans and tea leaves have been studied extensively for their potential health benefits.

First up, is the OG wake-me-up, coffee. Brewed coffee, in particular, is rich in chlorogenic acid, caffeic acid and melanoidin. Research shows these compounds may lower the risk of oxidative stress and brain inflammation, and reduce the risk of chronic diseases like Parkinson’s and Alzheimer’s.

In fact, according to Harvard Medical School, brewed coffee may also reduce high blood pressure and control blood sugar levels. This may help with conditions like type 2 diabetes and heart disease. Crucially, caffeine intake may also enhance metabolism, aiding weight loss.

Further still, caffeine in coffee may reduce the risk of certain cancers, including colon and liver cancer. Up to four cups of coffee daily, scientists say, improves physical performance, thanks to the prized energy boost.

But hey, let’s not sleep on tea, shall we? Tea offers high antioxidant properties due to its active catechins, flavonoids and polyphenols. These compounds may help tea drinkers improve brain health, reduce inflammation, enhance weight loss and prevent heart disease.

Black tea in a pot

However, unlike in coffee, caffeine in tea works together with these antioxidants. This synergism promotes day-long alertness without any of the jitters and much-dreaded crashes.

Additionally, certain caffeinated tea varieties, such as green and black tea, contain L-theanine. This compound may improve mental clarity, relaxation and better sleep.

That cup of tea sure goes a long way to preventing various health conditions, particularly cardiovascular disease, diabetes and consequently, early death!

Energy and Focus

For many, their everyday coffee is synonymous with an instant energy boost and enhanced mental alertness. Thanks to its high caffeine content, coffee does really put you in a good mood! A cup of coffee delivers a swift kick-start to the central nervous system, and this gets your mind and body going.

Coffee does this by stimulating the release of neurotransmitters like dopamine, serotonin and norepinephrine. What follows is a surge in brain activity and an energy boost that improves focus and concentration. This is what makes coffee so popular as a morning pick-me-up.

However, when drinking tea and coffee, I must urge caution. Too much caffeine may have adverse side effects, including anxiety, insomnia, nausea and restlessness. To this end, health professionals recommend no more than 400 milligrams of caffeine per day. In layman’s terms this equals four cups of coffee or eight cups of green tea. Alternatively, stick to the decaf!

While tea may not pack the same caffeine punch in the coffee vs tea caffeine battle, it offers a more sustained approach to boosting energy and mental focus, and has a calming effect.

Furthermore, the amino acid L-theanine, works with various compounds to promote a state of relaxed alertness. This unique combination can improve day-long attention spans, memory retention and creative thinking.

Whichever beverage you choose, you must drink water. This is because as refreshing as these beverages are, they’re both diuretics. In fact, health professionals recommend drinking plain water between cups of coffee or tea to stay hydrated.

Possible Weight Loss Benefits

Tea and coffee are popular choices in the quest for a trimmer waistline. And boy, do we need it! Just over 42 percent of Americans are battling obesity. Each drink has a unique blend of bioactive compounds that promote fat burning and weight loss.

But how do coffee and tea compare when it comes to shedding those extra pounds?

Thanks to its high caffeine content, coffee is famous for its potential to rev up fat-burning.

Does Decaf Coffee Have Caffeine

Firstly, caffeine stimulates the central nervous system, which in turn boosts your metabolic rate. This eventually increases calorie expenditure and hence weight loss. Additionally, coffee contains chlorogenic acid, which can block the absorption of carbohydrates. In turn, this leads to lower blood sugar levels and reduced fat storage.

Undoubtedly, we need more research to fully understand these biomechanisms. Still, the bottom line is, initial studies show that regular coffee consumption may help with weight loss

What about tea? How does it compare in the weight loss Olympics?

Tea can also be instrumental in achieving weight loss. Green tea and black tea, in particular, are full of catechins, flavonoids and polyphenols that suppress the appetite. This makes green and black tea popular for shedding those excess pounds. Moreover, black and green tea contain caffeine, which is instrumental in fat burning.

More so than caffeinated black tea, herbal teas, such as peppermint and ginger, help you lose weight by promoting healthy digestion. The catechins and flavonoids in them boost your metabolism, which in turn, helps you burn through fat faster. Crucially, herbal tea also has other special functions: reducing bloating and water retention.

Coffee vs Tea: Which Is Healthier?

I hope that you’ve gotten the lowdown on the coffee vs tea debate by reading this short but informative post.

Whether you prefer to drink coffee or tea, both beverages have unique qualities and health benefits. In most people, coffee offers a potent dose of caffeine that gets them through the day. It also provides an energy boost, improves brain function and metabolism.

Conversely, as a tea drinker, you’ll enjoy a gentler caffeine boost and a rich array of health-promoting antioxidants. These are vital in preventing heart disease, cancer, insulin sensitivity and obesity.

At the end of the day, both coffee and tea can enhance your well-being and form part of a healthy, balanced diet and lifestyle. Besides, the true measure of a beverage’s “healthiness” lies not only in its nutritional profile, but also in the joy and satisfaction it brings you. Happy caffeinating!

What do you think of the current coffee vs tea debate? Do you incorporate tea or coffee in your daily routine? Looking forward to your views in our community section below!

Coffee vs Tea FAQ

It depends. Coffee has more caffeine, which boosts brain function, boosts energy levels, regulates blood sugar levels and enhances metabolic rates. Tea, in particular, has potent antioxidants called catechins and polyphenols, which improve heart health and lower the risk of cancer. At the end of the day both tea and coffee in moderation offer significant health benefits.

It depends on your personal preference. Coffee offers a robust caffeine kick and strong energy boost, while teas provide a milder, all-day-long pick-me-up. Crucially, both tea and coffee have caffeine. However, tea has a lower amount of caffeine and is less acidic. It also contains L-theanine, which helps with sleep, lowers high blood pressure and boosts immune protection.

There’s no definitive answer to this coffee vs tea question. Factors such as weight, age, metabolism and sensitivity affect a person’s caffeine tolerance. It’s essential to be mindful of your caffeine intake and listen to your body’s cues to determine which beverage works best for you.

Yes. Tea is less acidic and contains less caffeine than coffee, making it gentler on the stomach.

Your coffee expert
Team Image
Arne Preuss

Hi! My name is Arne. Having spent years working as a barista I'm now on a mission to bring more good coffee to the people. To that end, my team and I provide you with a broad knowledge base on the subject of coffee.

More about Arne Preuss

Hi! My name is Arne. Having spent years working as a barista I'm now on a mission to bring more good coffee to the people. To that end, my team and I provide you with a broad knowledge base on the subject of coffee.

More about Arne Preuss

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Table of Contents